Food for Thought – “So perhaps those with no sense of rhythm should not dance?”

These are the wise words of the lovely María from Bilingual Being Non Native who commented this to me during a chat earlier this year, she also shared them on her first podcast (10min35).  They struck me as speaking the truth.

Why should making the gift of another language to your child be the privilege of natives?  Here are my 5 reflections on the topic:

  1. If you are eager to get on board this incredible bilingual adventure, work on your own minority language (ml) and at least give your child a headstart in life, why not?  So long as it is done with common sense (language strategy in keeping with your ml level), it is always better than nothing. It does not have to be perfect.  Mistakes can always be corrected later on in life; nothing is irreversible.  Giving the love of languages to your child will empower them for life with advanced language learning skills.
  2. Being a native is not a guarantee that the person has an extensive ml knowledge.  Some people are not interested in language learning and literacy.  Conversely, you can have very cultivated non-natives with a passion for language learning and literacy who can have an ml level equivalent to that of the native I just described.
  3. Committed non-natives will usually make the extra effort to strengthen their ml – They are conscious of their “weaker” position compared with a native; they often are willing to go the extra mile to improve their ml.  A native will not usually question their mother-tongue because it comes to them so naturally.
  4. The key is love, not the native language – Some natives sometimes hate the burden of passing on their heritage language so much that they give up (I have talked to one of them), others are simply uninterested in passing on their heritage.  On the other hand, some non-natives can be passionate about it and successfully pass on another language to their child.  
  5. Expressing one’s feelings in another language is not an issue – as you might have already read my thoughts on this in this previous post.

So before judging non-native parents, let’s give some serious thoughts about them raising their children bilingual: why shouldn’t they when they are able and willing to commit?  They should earn respect from the community, not jealousy at them entering what is perceived as an elite.

As my lovely sidekick Raquel at SpanglishEasy once told me: you teach your child to kick a football yet you ain’t a professional football player.  So why should you be a native to pass on another language?

2 Comments

  1. This is such a nice supportive post! All very true but sometimes it’s easy to get bogged down in an inability to provide perfect input and thinking you shouldn’t bother (or that people will think badly of you for trying). This is a really good post to return to whenever it seems to just not be working 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s the problem: nothing can be perfect! Let’s stop putting so much pressure on ourselves and stick to doing our best! 🙂 As to what people think, let them be and enjoy living our life. Raising our kids bilingual is nothing of their business. 😉

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.